Skip to content

Square Golf Launch Monitor vs Garmin R10: Your Room Picks the Winner

The content on Golfers Authority may contain advertisements, sponsored content, affiliate links, or other forms of monetization.

Before you compare a single number on these two, measure the room you’re going to hit in. That one measurement decides more of this than any spec sheet.

The Quick Verdict

If you’re building a simulator in a garage or a spare bedroom that’s short on depth, get the Square Golf HE. It sits right next to the ball, so it doesn’t need ball flight to read your shot, it tracks chipping and putting, and there’s no subscription. The trade is that it stays indoors, and it doesn’t give you clubhead speed or smash factor at all.

If you want one launch monitor for the range in the summer and the garage in the winter, and you’ve got the depth for it, get the Garmin Approach R10. It costs less up front, it reports clubhead speed, smash factor and club path, and it works outside. Just know that it lives behind you, it runs through your phone, and the full course-play experience is a yearly membership.

They Solve the Same Problem, Just From Different Spots

Both of these are the budget way into a home simulator. Neither one has a screen. You run both of them through an app on your phone or tablet, and both connect to the big third-party simulator programs like GSPro, E6 Connect and Awesome Golf. So if your end goal is a net, a mat and a course on a screen, either one gets you there. And if you’re still shopping the whole field, here are all of our launch monitor and simulator reviews.

Where they split is how they see the ball. The Square is a camera system, with two high-speed cameras and infrared sensors. The R10 is a Doppler radar. Everything else in this comparison, the room, the data, the range, comes back to that one difference. If you want the deeper version of that, here’s how photometric and radar launch monitors compare.

FeatureSquare Golf HEGarmin R10
Price$699$499.99
How it reads the ballTwo high-speed cameras with infrared sensorsDoppler radar
Where it sitsBeside the ball6 to 8 ft behind the ball
Indoor or outdoorIndoor onlyIndoor and outdoor
Clubhead speed and smash factorNot reportedReported
Club data4 club metrics, with shaft stickersClub path, face angle and angle of attack, no stickers
SpinBest with Square’s marked ballsCalculated from what the radar measures
Chipping and puttingTrackedNo putting in Home Tee Hero rounds
Native course play1,000 credits included, one credit per holeHome Tee Hero, 43,000+ courses, Garmin Golf membership
Recurring feeNone$99.99 a year for Home Tee Hero
Warranty2 years, device only (retailer-stated)1 year limited

The Room Decides This Before the Specs Do

The Square fits a room the R10 can’t, and that’s the whole reason it exists. Because it reads the shot right at impact, it doesn’t care how far the ball flies before it hits the net. Here’s how I put it in my Square video: it’s a side-mounted, camera-based system that sits next to the ball instead of behind it, and that means you don’t need 16 feet of space.

Now look at what the R10 asks for. Garmin says to put it on the ground 6 to 8 feet behind the ball, and when you’re indoors, the ball has to be at least 8 feet from the net. Do the math and that’s 14 to 16 feet from the monitor to the net. And that’s before you add room behind the net and enough space to swing a driver without hitting anything. If you’re planning around the R10, here’s the full breakdown of the Garmin R10 space requirements.

Here’s the thing, though. The Square isn’t a free pass on space. You still need enough height and width to make a full swing safely, and a net that’s set up right. It just takes depth off the table, and depth is the thing most garages run out of first.

Launch monitor set on a golf course

The R10 Gives You More Swing Numbers, the Square Gives You Putting

If you care about speed, the R10 wins easily. It reports clubhead speed and smash factor. The Square HE doesn’t report either one. The hell? That’s a weird pair to skip on a $699 launch monitor, because smash factor is how you know you’re hitting the middle of the face and clubhead speed is the first number most guys want on driver.

The R10 also gives you club path, face angle and angle of attack without anything stuck to your clubs. To be fair, not every one of those is measured directly. Spin, face angle, distance and deviation are calculated from what the radar picks up. If you want the deeper dive on that unit, read my full Garmin R10 review.

The Square gets its club data a different way. You put the included reflective stickers on your shafts to get its 4 club metrics, and you hit Square’s marked balls for the best spin numbers. Ball speed and carry are solid on any ball, but spin moves around without the marked ones. That’s not unusual for a camera system, and it’s a fair trade at the price.

Now, here’s where the Square pulls ahead. It tracks chipping and putting. The R10 doesn’t do putting in a Home Tee Hero round at all. Garmin adds 0 to 3 strokes based on how close your approach finishes. So if you want to actually putt out on your simulator, that’s the Square. Here’s my full Square Golf launch monitor review if you want everything on that one.

Golf launch monitor and accessories arranged on a table

Only One of These Goes to the Range

The Square HE is indoor only, period. Sunlight interferes with the cameras and infrared sensors, so you’re not taking it to the range. If your practice plan includes any outdoor golf, it’s the wrong tool.

The R10 is the opposite. It’s portable, it works indoors and outdoors, and it reads off natural grass, so you can take it to the range and use it like a normal practice session. In the Garmin Golf app you get a Driving Range mode with shot data and session stats, and it saves your sessions. You can also turn on Swing Capture, which uses your phone’s camera to record your swings and attach your numbers to them. That’s your phone doing the filming, not a camera in the R10.

Square Charges You by the Hole, Garmin Charges You by the Year

Neither one makes you pay just to hit balls on its own driving range, and that’s good. Where they split is course play.

The Square uses credits for its own course software. Every hole you play costs one credit, and it ships with 1,000 of them. That works out to more than 50 full rounds before you reload. Its native driving range doesn’t eat credits, and there’s no subscription. It also connects to GSPro, E6 Connect and Awesome Golf without a connection fee. Just know you still buy the GSPro or E6 license yourself. Square just doesn’t charge you to plug into it.

The R10’s own course mode is Home Tee Hero, with over 43,000 courses. That needs a Garmin Golf membership, which is $99.99 a year or $9.99 a month. And the membership doesn’t buy you GSPro or E6 Connect either. Those are separate purchases, and you hook them up through the Garmin Golf app.

Let’s do the math out loud. Over three years with the membership, the R10 comes to $799.96. The Square is $699 up front, plus whatever course credits you buy after the included ones run out. So the R10 starts cheaper, and which one finishes cheaper comes down to how much course golf you play. If you hate subscriptions in general, here are the best launch monitors with no subscription.

Presenter beside an indoor golf simulator screen

What I Don’t Love About Each

Here’s the limitation with both. Neither one is a club fitter’s tool. If you’re a coach, a fitter, or you need tour-level precision on every number, skip both of these and save up for something a lot more expensive. These are for building a home setup you’ll actually use, not for fitting a shaft.

Square Golf HE

Paul’s score: 4.6/5

There’s a catch. There’s always a catch. Dynamic loft, one of the club numbers it does give you, is often way off. And it can be a little flaky with shot detection. I’d say maybe every dozen or so swings, a shot won’t register. That’s not a dealbreaker for casual play, but it’s annoying when you’re grinding on something. The build is pretty plasticky and light, and this thing sits inches from a ball you’re hitting at full speed. The Swing Stick in the box, which lets you swing without hitting a ball, is a novelty more than a training tool. And the app doesn’t keep much of a shot history, so tracking progress over time is tough.

Garmin R10

Paul’s score: 4.5/5

The downside is spin. It’s the R10’s weakest number. It’s solid on a well-struck driver or long iron, but on wedges and mishits it gets shaky. And it’s fussy about aim. Its ball and club angles are measured relative to the target line, so you have to line up the red alignment line on the unit with the ball and your target. A small unit that’s aimed a little off can push your face and path numbers a degree or two.

Who Should Buy Which

Buy the Square Golf HE if:

  • Your room is too short to put a radar unit behind you
  • You want to chip and putt on your simulator, not just hit full shots
  • You hate yearly fees and want course play included
  • You’ll only ever hit indoors

Best for: Short indoor rooms and putting

Square Golf Launch Monitor

Upgrade your indoor golf setup with the Square Golf Launch Monitor. This camera-based simulator delivers highly accurate ball and club data for under $1,000. Enjoy realistic gameplay with no expensive subscriptions. Perfect for compact home spaces!

Pros:
  • Works in a tight room
  • Reads putting
  • No subscription
Cons:
  • Indoor only
  • No club head speed or smash factor
  • Case is a $69.99 add-on
Buy at PlayBetter

Buy the Garmin R10 if:

  • You want clubhead speed and smash factor on every swing
  • You want to take it to the range as well as use it at home
  • You’ve got the depth behind the ball and in front of the net
  • You don’t mind running everything through your phone

Best for: Range and home in one unit

Garmin Approach R10
4.8

Experience advanced golf tracking with the Garmin Approach R10, a premium launch monitor delivering precise data and improving your game effortlessly.

Pros:
  • Compact and portable
  • Provides 14 key ball and club metrics
  • Long battery life (10 hours)
Cons:
  • No screen on the device
  • Club data less reliable with short irons and wedges
  • Home Tee Hero needs a Garmin Golf membership ($99.99/yr)
Buy on PlayBetter

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Square Golf a good launch monitor?

Yes, if you’re using it indoors in a tight space. It reads the ball from the side at impact, so it works where radar units struggle, and it tracks putting. Just know it doesn’t report clubhead speed or smash factor, and it doesn’t work outside.

Is the Garmin R10 worth it in 2026?

Yes, for most golfers who want one unit for the range and home. At $499.99 it still gives you club path, angle of attack, clubhead speed and smash factor, and it connects to the major simulator programs. Skip it if your room can’t give it 14 to 16 feet from the monitor to the net.

Does the Square Golf launch monitor need a subscription?

No. There’s no subscription. Its own course software runs on credits, one per hole, and the unit comes with 1,000 of them. The driving range doesn’t use credits. You’ll still pay for third-party software like GSPro or E6 if you want it.

Can you use the Square Golf launch monitor outdoors?

No. The Square HE is indoor only, because sunlight interferes with its cameras and infrared sensors. If you want a launch monitor for the range too, the R10 works indoors and outdoors.

What golf balls can you use with the Square launch monitor?

You can hit any golf ball and still get solid ball speed and carry. For the best spin numbers, use Square’s marked balls. Three come with the unit.

Final Thoughts on Square Golf HE vs Garmin R10

Both of these get you into a home simulator on a budget, and neither one is trying to be a fitter’s tool. What separates them is where each one sits and how much room that takes.

So it comes down to one call. If your room is short, buy the Square and don’t look back. If it isn’t, and you’d take a launch monitor to the range even a few times a year, buy the R10.

Paul Liberatore

About the author

Paul Liberatore

Paul Liberatore is the founder of Golfers Authority and a former three-year golf gear contributor to Sports Illustrated. He tests golf equipment hands-on to help golfers make better buying decisions.