When I pulled the PXG Sugar Daddy II wedge out of its packaging, my initial thought was "another $500 wedge trying to justify its price tag." I've tested enough premium wedges over the years to be skeptical when brands throw around terms like "triple-forged" and "precision-weighted." But holding this club in my hands, something felt different. The 8620 soft carbon steel has a density to it that you don't get with cast wedges, and the CNC-milled face looked like it was machined by a Swiss watchmaker.
The high-toe shape immediately caught my eye; it's not quite as exaggerated as some specialty wedges I've tested, but it's definitely more pronounced than your standard Vokey or Cleveland. After spending three weeks playing with these wedges (I tested both the 54° and 58° models in the C Grind), I can tell you this: PXG might actually have something special here. Designed by Mike Nicolette, PXG's director of product creation, these wedges represent a serious engineering effort to push wedge technology forward. It's worth noting that Hudson Swafford recently validated their tour-level performance by using two Sugar Daddy II wedges in his American Express victory.
Step up your short game with the PXG Sugar Daddy II Wedges, crafted for precision and unmatched control. These 100% milled wedges feature advanced weight customization and high-performance design to help you master every shot around the green.
Let me explain why the construction process of these wedges isn't just marketing fluff. Most wedges you'll find are either cast (poured into a mold) or forged once, maybe twice if the manufacturer is feeling fancy. PXG takes their 8620 soft carbon steel through three separate forging processes, and here's what that actually does: it compresses and aligns the grain structure of the metal in a way that creates both durability and feel. I've put about 500 balls through my test wedges, including plenty of bunker shots and rough lies, and the grooves still look fresh. More crucially, the feel at impact has this distinctive "click" that's crisp without being harsh; it's like the difference between hitting a ProV1 and a range ball.
The CNC milling that happens after forging is where things get really precise. Every groove, every surface, every angle is cut to exact specifications. I measured the grooves with my calipers (yes, I'm that guy), and they're pushed right to the USGA limit. What does this mean for you? Maximum legal spin, consistently, across every wedge they produce. I've tested wedges from other manufacturers where you can feel slight variations between two "identical" clubs – not here.
Here's the kicker: that Xtreme Dark finish they provide for an extra $100? It's not just cosmetic. The darker finish actually reduces glare at address, which I found surprisingly helpful during those bright afternoon rounds. Is it worth the upcharge? That depends on your budget, but after testing both finishes, I found myself preferring the dark option.
This is where the Sugar Daddy II really separated itself from my current gamers. The full-face groove design means the grooves extend all the way across the face and up into that high-toe area. I was skeptical about how much this would actually matter. After all, how often do you really hit it that far toward the toe? Turns out, more than I thought. When you open the face for those delicate flop shots or bunker escapes, the ball contact point naturally moves toward the toe. With traditional wedges, you're hitting a smoother area with less groove coverage. With these PXG wedges, you're still getting full groove engagement.
I set up a test on my home course's practice green, hitting 50 shots from 30 yards with an open face, intentionally varying my strike location. With my old wedge (a two-year-old Titleist SM8), toe strikes would come out lower with less check. With the Sugar Daddy II, the difference in spin between center strikes and toe strikes was almost negligible; we're talking maybe 200-300 RPM difference compared to 800-1000 RPM with traditional grooves. That consistency translates to more predictable results when you're trying to stick it close from awkward lies.
The high MOI design from that toe weighting also helps here. Even when I caught one thin (it happens to all of us), the ball still had enough spin to check on the green instead of racing past the pin. It's not magic, you still need decent contact, but it's noticeably more forgiving than what I'm used to.
The adjustable weight system near the center of gravity initially seemed like overkill to me. I mean, how much customization does a wedge really need? But after working with it, I'm converted. The weight port lets you dial in the swing weight to match your other clubs or adjust for personal preference. I tend to like my wedges slightly heavier than standard (helps me maintain tempo on partial shots), and being able to add a few grams made a noticeable difference in my consistency from 80-100 yards.
What surprised me was how the weight placement affected the complete feel of the club. With the weight positioned low and centered, these wedges feel incredibly stable through impact. You know that sensation when you catch one perfect, and the club just seems to swing itself through the ball? That happens more often with these than with any wedge I've tested. The weight also seems to help with distance control. I found my partial wedge shots flying more consistent yardages, even when my strike wasn't perfect.
For fitters, this is a significant advancement. Instead of having to build up grips or add lead tape (which affects the balance point), you can precisely tune each wedge's swing weight while maintaining the designed balance. It's the kind of feature that tour players have access to with their custom builds, now available to the rest of us.
PXG offers two sole grinds: the C Grind (10° bounce, narrow sole) and the BP Grind (13° bounce, wider sole). I tested the C Grind because I play firm conditions most of the year and like to manipulate the face, but I also got my hands on a BP Grind for comparison. The difference is more dramatic than the numbers suggest.
The C Grind is clearly designed for better players who want versatility. The narrow sole with moderate bounce lets you open the face without the leading edge lifting too much, and it cuts through firm turf beautifully. I could hit everything from low spinners to high flops without the sole fighting me. The relief on the trailing edge is perfectly balanced, enough to prevent digging but not so much that you lose stability.
The BP Grind is a different animal entirely. That wider sole with 13° bounce is perfect if you play in soft conditions or tend to hit behind the ball occasionally (no judgment, we all do it). It's more forgiving on fat shots and excels from fluffy lies, but you sacrifice some versatility. Opening the face adds significant effective bounce, which can make delicate shots from tight lies more challenging.
Here's my only real complaint: I wish PXG offered a low-bounce option. For players who really like to flight their wedges down or play on extremely firm conditions, neither grind is ideal. You're looking at 10° minimum, which might be too much for some players and conditions.
I'm usually skeptical when manufacturers claim superior spin rates, but I brought these to my local club fitter, who has a GCQuad launch monitor, and the numbers backed up what I was feeling. On full shots, the Sugar Daddy II was generating 500-800 more RPMs than my current wedges on identical strikes. On partial shots from 50 yards, the difference was even more pronounced; we're talking about 1000+ additional RPMs compared to my well-worn wedges. Modern launch monitors like the Square Golf can track spin rates from -2000 to 12000 rpm, providing precise feedback for wedge testing and fitting.
But here's what really matters: that spin is usable. High spin is great, but if you can't control it, you're going to be spinning balls back off greens. The Sugar Daddy II generates what I call "heavy" spin; the ball lands, takes one hop, and stops. On several occasions, I actually had to adjust my landing spots because balls were checking harder than expected. From 80-110 yards (my bread and butter full wedge range), the path and spin combination was ideal, high enough to stop quickly but not ballooning in the wind.
The single groove specification across all lofts is an interesting choice. Some manufacturers vary their grooves by loft, but PXG's approach ensures consistent spin characteristics whether you're hitting a 50° or a 60°. After testing multiple lofts, I appreciate this consistency; it makes it easier to predict how each wedge will react.
Step up your short game with the PXG Sugar Daddy II Wedges, crafted for precision and unmatched control. These 100% milled wedges feature advanced weight customization and high-performance design to help you master every shot around the green.
You'll find PXG Sugar Daddy II wedges are manufactured in the United States at PXG's domestic production facilities. The company doesn't outsource to overseas third-party manufacturers; instead maintains complete control over its entire production process from forging to final milling. They manage everything in-house, including inventory and parts, which supports their fast shipping and customization options. This vertical integration guarantees quality control and allows them to respond quickly to market demand.
Your PXG Sugar Daddy II wedges come with a one-year warranty from the original purchase date. This covers defects in materials and workmanship when you're using them normally. If you're buying pre-owned wedges, they're still covered for up to one year from when they were initially purchased - not from when you bought them used. The warranty isn't transferable, so it only applies if you're the original owner.
Yes, you can trade in your old wedges for credit toward new PXG Sugar Daddy II wedges through PXG's partnership with 2nd Swing Golf. You'll use their online valuation tool to get a quote based on your wedges' condition, then ship them with a prepaid label for $9.99. Once 2nd Swing verifies the condition, you'll receive credit within 3 business days. There's no limit on how many wedges you can trade.
You'll spend about 2 hours for a full bag fitting at PXG locations, while woods-only or irons-only fittings take around 60 minutes each. If you're just getting wedges fitted, expect about an hour since they're part of the irons category. Putter fittings are quickest at 30 minutes. Your session includes analyzing your current clubs, testing different configurations, and reviewing performance data to dial in your perfect specs.
You'll find left-handed Sugar Daddy II wedges in 54°, 56°, 58°, and 60° lofts, but they're not always available for every option. While these four main lofts exist in left-handed versions, you won't consistently find all loft and bounce combinations in stock like you would with right-handed models. Availability varies by retailer and fluctuates over time, so you'll need to check multiple sources or consider special ordering specific configurations.
So here's the bottom line: at $499 per wedge (or $599 for the Xtreme Dark), the PXG Sugar Daddy II wedges are undeniably expensive. But unlike some premium alternatives that are all marketing and no substance, these deliver performance that justifies the investment, if you can afford it. The combination of triple-forged construction, full-face grooves, and precision weighting creates a wedge that's both forgiving for average players and precise enough for scratch golfers.
These wedges are perfect for the serious golfer who plays multiple times per week and can appreciate (and take advantage of) the technical advantages. If you're someone who's constantly working on their short game and wants equipment that won't hold you back, these are worth every penny. However, if you play once a month or are still working on basic contact, save your money and grab something in the $150-200 range. The Sugar Daddy II wedges are exceptional tools, but like any precision instrument, they're only as good as the person wielding them.
